Skip to main content
Frank Agullo, MD En Español Open Menu

What a Plastic Surgeon Actually Sees in a Face at 59: The Faith Hill “Unrecognizable” Debate, Read From the Exam Chair

November 21, 2026 | Facelift, Facial Procedures, Plastic Surgery

A woman around sixty with chestnut-brown hair looks into a hand mirror in a consultation room while a surgeon's gloved finger lifts her brow. Illustrative generated image, not a patient, not Faith Hill. What a surgeon sees in a face at 59, Frank Agullo, MD, FACS, El Paso, Texas.

Faith Hill, 59, sat in the crowd at the CMA Awards on Wednesday to watch Tim McGraw win, and by Friday Hello! was reporting that fans found her “unrecognizable.” New chestnut-brown hair, black satin, arena lights, phone cameras. She has not commented, and I have not examined her.

I do examine women her age every week. The full commentary, with what a camera and a hair color change, is on Dr. WorldWide. This is the surgical read, in my own words.

The Checklist

Two sets of photos of another actress this fall, months apart, for a press request. Same list I run on every face in my office.

“If you compare the two time frames and look at the brows, they sit in the same position. They have not been lifted. The excess upper eyelid skin remains. The volume of the cheeks is still in the same place, and the jawline is still sharp.”

“You can see that she has platysmal banding, that is, the two lines in the neck that look separated, so that goes against her having a neck lift, because this is usually repaired at the same time.”

“If you look at her hands, they really give away her true age and are definitely a mismatch with the way her face looks.”

Brow, lid skin, cheek volume, jawline, neck bands, hands. Hair color is not on the list. Weight is.

“As surgeons we know that 10 or 15 pounds makes a huge difference in the face, whether you gain it or lose it.”

Where the Brow Should Sit

A 60-year-old patient asked about her upper eyelids. The eyelids were not the problem.

“On men, the brow is right at the edge of the bone. But on a woman, it’s usually at least half an inch above. And that’s probably where your brow was. If you look at your pictures before, it was probably up here.”

The corners of the eyes tell the same story at this age.

“And I do notice, for example, the corners of your eyes have kind of turned down. You see how it’s kind of slanted this way? And before, you were pretty much horizontal.”

That is 59 with nothing done: brow on the bone, eye corners sloping, cheek volume slid, jawline softer. Anatomy, not a scandal.

What the Surgery Is For

Nobody comes to me at 59 to become a different person. They bring a picture of themselves at 45.

“We can usually do ten to fifteen years. So you’re at a very good age to get this done. We’ve been doing it earlier and earlier, because it does get you back to a younger and younger self.”

For this face it is usually the endoscopic ponytail lift with a deep plane release.

“So we would put an incision up here and another one down here. So you have two on each side, but they’re very small, and through there with the endoscope, I’m able to pretty much lift everything up, including the brow will come up and out a little bit, the cheek will come up, and the jowl itself will come up as well, and that’s gonna give you a really nice jawline.”

“It avoids the scar in front of the ear and in the temporal area, so most people will not know what happened, because they really can’t see any scars.”

“With this technique, even though it’s minimally invasive, it’s a deep plane facelift, so it gives you a long-lasting result. We are doing everything we do on an open deep plane facelift, so you’re getting the benefit of the best possible surgery, but with minimal incisions.”

“And then for the neck, there’s going to be a small incision right underneath your chin. And there will be a scar behind your ear, and with that, we can repair those bands on your neck and also pull the skin back so that you get a lot of the jawline definition, and the face and the neck both look rejuvenated.”

Weight First, Then the Face

“Preferably I want the patient to have lost the weight that they had planned and be weight stable after any facelift procedure. The reason being that oftentimes patients after a facelift tend to lose further weight. And of course, if we lose the volume, then we will have some aging. As the face deflates, the skin tends to sag. So we would lose a lot of the benefit of having done the facelift if the patient continues to lose weight.”

What It Looks Like After

The fear behind “unrecognizable” is the pulled face. That is not what a deep plane lift looks like.

“When I do facelifts, usually two or three times a week. So it’s something we do very routinely. You can look at a lot of my before and afters. They’re very natural, so you’re not going to look pulled, but you’re going to look younger.”

“This will give you about ten, fifteen years, and it is still subtle. You are not going to look pulled or overdone.”

“Two weeks is perfect. At two weeks, you’re looking almost back to normal. You may have some bruising that may need a little bit of makeup to hide, but that’s when most people go back to work.”

At 59, with nothing done What the ponytail and deep plane lift change
Brow resting on the orbital rim Brow back to half an inch above it
Eye corners sloping down Corners lifted toward horizontal
Cheek volume slid toward the jowl Cheek and jowl moved up together
Softer jawline, neck bands Jawline redefined, bands repaired
Scar worries Incisions in the hair and behind the ear

Facelift and neck lift fees are on the fees page, as of this writing. What a facelift looks like after weight loss is here, and what holds at 18 months is here. The non-surgical side, what a neuromodulator and skin treatments can change at 59 and what they cannot, is on Southwest Plastic Surgery.

Why Choose Dr. Agullo

I am certified by the American Board of Plastic Surgery and the American Board of Surgery, completed my plastic surgery fellowship at the Mayo Clinic, and teach as Clinical Associate Professor of Plastic Surgery at Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center. Castle Connolly has listed me as a Top Doctor every year from 2014 through 2026. Every facelift is done in our own QUAD A accredited Class C surgery center, and I do two or three a week.

Ready to Talk?

Bring the picture of yourself at 45 and we will talk about the ten to fifteen years in between. Call (915) 590-7900, text 1-866-814-0038, or book online at agulloplasticsurgery.com/appointments. #StayBeautiful

Find me at @RealDrWorldWide on Instagram, TikTok, and Snapchat, @Agullo on X, or @AgulloPlasticSurgery on Facebook.